A psychological horror costumed as a biopic
Anna Hamilton on 'The Leader'
by Anna Hamilton
The 1997 Heaven’s Gate mass suicide remains the largest to ever take place on US soil. It was the culmination of Marshall Herff Applewhite and his 38 followers spending decades striving to “overcome” their own humanity in order to reach what he and cult co-leader Bonnie Lu Nettles had named “The Next Evolutionary Level Above Human.”
The group had been living in a rented mansion in Rancho Santa Fe, near San Diego, for several years before they took their own lives in spectacular fashion. In late 1996, after hearing a radio segment on conspiracy theorist Art Bell’s Coast to Coast AM about a spaceship supposedly traveling behind the Hale-Bopp comet, the group made preparations for their “transition” to meet their alien brethren aboard the ship. Settled in for their cosmic journey on bunkbeds, the members were all dressed alike in black tracksuits, with their feet clad in new Nike Decades sneakers. The final touch was purple shrouds covering the bodies, a tribute to the late Nettles.
In the 29 years since their “exit,” there have been a few documentaries made about the cult, most notably the four-hour 2020 HBO Max series Heaven’s Gate: The Cult of Cults, directed by Clay Tweel. A new narrative feature, writer-director Michael J. Gallagher’s The Leader, tells another version of the group’s story with some fictionalized elements. At first glance it might seem like a standard biopic that purports to examine what exactly made Bonnie (Ti) and Herff (Do) tick – the duo took their nicknames from the tones on the musical scale sung in The Sound of Music’s “Do Re Mi” – and why they led the group to an end here on Earth, but to Gallagher’s immense credit as a screenwriter and director, The Leader is anything but standard. The film takes much of its inspiration from psychological horror tropes throughout its 106-minute run time. Even if we, as viewers, know how this story ends, the use of these tropes is still incredibly effective. At its core, this is a movie about human relationships, and what happens when vulnerable people rely too heavily on a messiah figure who purports to have all the answers to their earthly problems.